Reblog: God is the Cause of Both ‘Evil’ and ‘Sin’ — via Steven Colborne of Perfect Chaos

Dear friends, the following article has been replicated here in its entirety from a fellow WordPress blogger’s post:  God is the Cause of Both ‘Evil’ and ‘Sin’ — by Steven Colborne, Perfect Chaos, June 2, 2020. It came to my attention because Steven had starred my own latest; a poem which re-explores the concept of Samsara.

I am not religious per se, if anything tending mostly toward Zen Buddhism; but having a background in Linguistics I am very interested in language and the way we use it. Having having a spiritu-philosophical bent, I also tend to gravitate toward the idea of divine direction in all creation.

Though we like-minded folks might not all use the same language, the impressions and ideas in Steven’s post jive in many ways with my own ponderings/beliefs, and perhaps with some of yours as well. I loved reading this thoughtfully-curated, Christianity-examining perspective. I think it’s a fantastic article, and Steven’s book, God’s Grand Game, sounds like one I’d love to read.

I hope it’s okay that I share the post here. Steven has closed comments on it for reasons therein stated. I assume my urge to repost this is all within GOD’s great plan (or “Good Orderly Direction,” as I and others sometimes like to call it ;)).

Much love, and gratitude to you all, for reading and writing, xoxoxo “Lia”

God is the Cause of Both ‘Evil’ and ‘Sin’
by Steven Colborne, Perfect Chaos, June 2, 2020

For today’s post in my Praise and Prose series, I’d like to discuss how our use of language might change in order to reflect the truth that God is in control of everything that happens which Christians (and people of other faiths) describe as ‘sin’ and ‘evil’.

First, I will present a series of scriptures from the Bible that reflect the fact that God is in control of both ‘evil’ and ‘sin’ and I will then make a few relevant points in relation to our use of language.

But I will harden Pharaoh’s heart, and though I multiply my signs and wonders in the land of Egypt, Pharaoh will not listen to you. Then I will lay my hand on Egypt and bring my hosts, my people the children of Israel, out of the land of Egypt by great acts of judgment.
(Exodus 7:3-4)

Is it not from the mouth of the Most High that both calamities and good things come?
(Lamentations 3:38)

When a trumpet sounds in a city, do not the people tremble? When disaster comes to a city, has not the Lord caused it?
(Amos 3:6)

I form the light and create darkness, I bring prosperity and create disaster; I, the Lord, do all these things.
(Isaiah 45:7)

Now the spirit of the Lord had departed from Saul, and an evil spirit from the Lord tormented him.
(1 Samuel 16:14)

And if a prophet is deceived into giving a message, it is because I, the Lord, have deceived that prophet. I will lift my fist against such prophets and cut them off from the community of Israel.
(Ezekiel 14:9)

 

The first passage I quoted was Exodus 7:3-4. God hardens Pharaoh’s heart, but subsequently punishes the Egyptians for actions He has caused. The fact that God hardens people’s hearts is an indication that He is in control of those aspects of our lives which the Bible describes as transgressions. But if God has caused them, are they really transgressions?

We could try to come to an understanding of how it’s possible to believe in the Christian worldview and that God is in control of our transgressions. But how are we to make sense of sin, judgement, and salvation, if we do not freely transgress, and if all of our transgressions are brought about by God?

In my book God’s Grand Game I spend a chapter discussing what I call ‘modes of mind’. One of the modes of mind that God sometimes gives people manifests as a feeling that they are acting freely, even though in reality they are merely puppets in God’s hands. The reason why I use the word ‘game’ in my book’s title is because this word reflects the playful nature of God giving us the illusion of free will, when in reality we are not free.

According to what I have just stated, our sins could be a part of God’s grand game. This is the only way I can make sense of the scriptures that I have quoted in relation to Christianity. But I must note that most Christians insist that we sin freely, and their whole worldview rests on this idea. They do not believe God is in control of their sins at all.

The scriptures I have quoted indicate that God is sovereign over all events, which I believe is the absolute Truth. So perhaps we should stop saying prayers that indicate satan is in control of certain thoughts and behaviours, when really God is in control of all our thoughts and behaviours.

It’s possible that within the grand game, satan exists, and is playing out a role in which he can be seen to influence our lives. But we should not deny the reality that anything satan does is really under God’s control. A way of praying that would be true to reality would be one that denies satan’s free will and acknowledges God’s sovereignty over all events.

So, instead of saying a prayer such as, “Lord, bind satan!”, we might instead say, “Lord, use this difficult situation which you have caused in order to bring peace and joy”. Instead of praying for “the enemy” to be defeated, we should ask God to restore peace and healing where God has caused suffering and strife.

There is no such thing as a sin committed freely, because God is in sovereign control of all events. So, instead of praying for forgiveness, we might instead ask God to help us make sense of those experiences which He has caused in relation to which we may feel guilty. We might speak about our lives as though they are stories directed by God, rather than as though they are a constant battle against sins which we freely commit.


I hope this blog post has given readers some food for thought. I realise many Christians could find this post uncomfortable and provocative, so I have closed comments in line with my comments policy. Thank you for reading and God bless you.

(Photo by Michel Paz on Unsplash)

[~ Steven Colborne, Perfect Chaos]

N.B: Once again, the above text is copied here in its entirety, from the post called: God is the Cause of Both ‘Evil’ and ‘Sin’ — by Steven Colborne, Perfect Chaos, June 2, 2020

Many thanks to Steven for bringing it to my attention, via his kind support of some of my own work. Please visit and follow Perfect Chaos, if you appreciate what you’ve read here, by visiting the link immediately above; or, if you are a WordPress blogger, via WP Reader, here: https://wordpress.com/read/blogs/32394414/posts/13595.

~ Lia The Poet (“Created on a whim,” and in agreement with the concept of “Perfect Chaos.” ;))  🏹💛💃🏼🔆🙏🌷

15 thoughts on “Reblog: God is the Cause of Both ‘Evil’ and ‘Sin’ — via Steven Colborne of Perfect Chaos

    1. I’m reading the “Look Inside” feature of his book on Amazon right now, very page-turning, clear language… section called “My journey so far”… grew up with atheist mother and Christian father, listened to Marilyn Manson and Rage Against the Machine… very relatable author in my view. :))

      Liked by 2 people

  1. i find this hard to swallow, still has the stench of human-exceptionalism, also credit where credit is due the Islamic religion has always taught this as a doctrine, that both good and evil are creations of god. yer i don’t think im much a subscriber to the notion of transcendent meaning, which is a direct by- product of a belief in a higher something. That being said i love good writing and this piece was well thought out, well approached and thoroughly entertaining! 🙂

    Liked by 2 people

    1. I love your comment, which adds to the conversation, and in Steven’s defence, and not knowing much about everything, I will say that it’s pretty hard to credit and mention any and all sources in a single article, same as it would be hard to know each blogger’s history, beliefs, knowledge and understandings via a single post or two. From what I have read of Steven’s book on Amazon in the past few moments, a lot more is explored and credited there. Thank you so much, Jason, for reading and saying what is likely on many people’s minds. :)) Hugs and I love your style. xoxo 💛

      Liked by 1 person

      1. No thank you for sharing, it’s a great piece. What sadden me most about this post-modern era is that it seems, if you disagree with a persons premises then it in some way makes it impossible for you to appreciate the artistry involved, which is total bs, as a free thinking individual you should be able look beyond your own ideas and beliefs, and extrapolate the beauty and artistry that goes into creating a piece like we just read. so yer kudos to you and Steven 🙂

        Liked by 1 person

        1. Wow! This is so beautifully said, and mirrors my won beliefs too… art needs to be appreciated in and of itself… which can be a true challenge, based on fact that we are feeling human beings, and biologically wired to make subjective judgements. Hugs for your kudos… and ye know I luvs yer “yers.” :))) xoxox

          Liked by 1 person

  2. Dear Lia,

    Just wanted to say a big thank you for reading and reposting my article, I’m really glad you found it interesting! And yes, I hope you get an opportunity to read God’s Grand Game, which gives a lot more context to the worldview touched upon in the post.

    Very best wishes to you and I’ll look forward to your future posts! 🙂

    Steven

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Hi Steven, thank you so much, I’m glad you are okay with it! I’ve already ordered the paperback, it’s on its way. Your style of writing seen via the “look inside” view was captivating! And I think we may think much alike. :)) Thanks again for your lovely support! 🙏💛🙏

      Liked by 1 person

      1. Oh wow, it’s a wonderful blessing to me that you enjoy my style of writing and have ordered a copy of God’s Grand Game, my heartfelt thanks to you! I hope you enjoy the book — please feel free to email me if you have any thoughts you’d like to share during or after reading the book.

        I’m going to make a cup of spicy chai now and explore some more of your blog posts 🙂

        Thank you for being so kind and such a blessing to me! I was already having a good day but you have made it even better!

        Peace and blessings ❤️

        Steven

        Liked by 1 person

        1. Awww that is so sweet! Thank you so much for these super super kind words! ❤️ I admit I have quite a few books on the go, but this one seemed too good to miss! Peace and blessings likewise… and enjoy the chai. :)) 🍵✨🍵

          Liked by 1 person

  3. Lia, read some of your more adventurous poetry. Like.

    It was thoughtful of you to repost.
    Mr Colborne articulately explains one view of the bible passages he uses as a proof for the world view he promotes. When the reader examines just those bible passages, it seems abundantly clear that the derived meaning is that God made the evil. There are other passages that Mr Colborne could also include to reinforce this view.
    Those who promote a different derived meaning can quote from other passages that appear to promote the exact opposite derived meaning. Both groups of people have their explanations of how to reconcile the two.
    And of course, there are levels of nuance that fall between and beyond the two groups.
    For many people, the above paragraphs I wrote encapsulate the reason to cease pursuing knowing God through the bible. If God wrote a book wouldn’t it be clear?
    I post this because I have travelled a long journey along a similar path. And I have found that the journey does lead to deeper understanding.
    If God wrote a book wouldn’t it be clear?
    If I handed these paragraphs to a young child that just learned to read, would it be clear?
    As another traveller on the journey, my encouragement to any reading this is: when you encounter the contradiction, it may be because of a fundamental misunderstanding. It may be that it is time to move up a little.

    May Love capture all of us. Soon.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Hi and welcome, AnonFort/Soon. I feel like you might be hailing from the same entity as Bukalor/Crumbs Point Vaguely. Thank you for the comment, and best wishes, Soon. :))

      Like

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.